Wednesday, October 11, 2006
Column: Landis Takes His Case to Internet
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Dan Marschka <luxamor@gmail.com>
Date: Oct 11, 2006 10:09 AM
Subject: Fwd: Column: Landis Takes His Case to Internet
To: fgirardot@gmail.com
Cc: dmarschka@lnpnews.com
Frank,
I thought you might want to read this email and Jim's recent column:
Hope you are well. If you see Floyd and his family, please tell him I
still hope for the best.
Dan
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Dan Marschka <luxamor@gmail.com>
Date: Oct 11, 2006 12:56 PM
Subject: re: Column: Landis Takes His Case to Internet
To: jlitke@ap.org
Jim,
You write your column as if it is a given that what cycling
authorities have claimed about Floyd Landis is fact.
He is judged and convicted in your eyes, so what is the point of
allowing him to defend himself - right?
What do you know for fact that has been attributed to Floyd? You know
what you have read. You are aware of nebulous test results from
experts you trust personally (?).
You do not know anything about Floyd the man or his determination to
clear his name except what you assume to be a desperate waste of time.
Consider that the conspiracy to smear him is true. Why would anyone do
that? I can think of many reasons.
Put yourself in Floyd's shoes. If he is telling the truth, what would
you do? Anything you could to raise doubt. Play the same game. Win.
You may be thinking - you are so naive. I would say the same thing to you.
If you believe Floyd's defense is a farce - defend the lab procedures,
defend the technical facts as to why levels are different one day and
not different on consecutive days.
Consider that he may also have been spiked by someone else - like a
cycling date rape cocktail.
Prove it to me and I will believe. Until then, your opinion is
meaningless and predictably cynical, as are most columnists that write
without doing sufficient research.
I am disappointed you are riding with the herd and not working harder
to delve deeper.
Lord help you write something that matters.
Regards,
Dan Marschka
Lititz, PA
Tuesday, October 10, 2006
LA Tribune?
10-10-06
Dear Mr. Kinsley,
I really enjoyed your article in the Times Sunday. I
worked at Los Angeles' greatest newspaper the
Herald-Examiner when it was in its death throes. Then,
as one of many writers for the Los Angeles News Group
during the 1990s my colleagues and I endured many of
the same cost cutting measures now being employed at
the Times. Much of the griping about implementing
so-called "economy of scale" had as much to do with
egos as with any effort to produce a good newspaper.
But, I was comforted, because I believed that somehow
management was implementing cost measures as a way of
preserving the job I was born to do and the job I
loved so much.
That said, I often reflect on what makes a good
newspaper. I think strong editorials, lively writing
and timely coverage are essential. The old Times
(perhaps before your tenure as editorial pages editor)
did very few of these things right. Editorials were
boring. Writing style was stuck in the 1970s and
timely coverage of real news events seldom occurred.
I can't tell you how many times a reporter would write
something for the Pasadena Star-News on Wednesday only
to see that story picked up (sometimes verbatim) on
Friday in the Times-- then get regional coverage via
radio and local tv and national attention via the wire
services.
As you pointed out Sunday, story placement could be
bizarre and it still is in many situations. Case in
point: a well-known local television reporter and
radio talk show host got picked up Sunday by the FBI
for suppossedly molesting two young boys in a sauna on
one of those Long Beach to Ensenada weekend cruises.
Where does the Times play this story? On B-5. WTF? KFI
led with the story all morning. Sure with the Foley
scandal and nukes in North Korea, this isn't
necessarily A-1 material, but I think it points out
why readers might turn to the Ventura
Who-Cares-What-It's-Called.
I really believe the first rule of good newspapering
is you've got to sell the fish wrap with the best
material out front -- and celebrity local reporter
nabbed in molestation sting is nothing if not a good
story -- even if it goes nowhere, there's a follow
people will want to read the next day.
Fortunately, over the past few years the paper has
morphed into something better -- in spite of whatever
mismanagement is being perpetuated. For example, I
believe the Times has one of the best and most
thorough sports sections of any paper in the country.
(Although of late they've been implementing some sort
of redesign that's cut into column inches and
ultimately depth.)
Tim Ruttan's thoughtful Saturday columns on media are
always worth a good read. The obits should be
mandatory reading for anyone who wants to learn how to
weave a good tale. The Times turning reportorial
muscle inward on itself has also made for good
newspapering of late.
I agree with you that selling the paper to Eli Broad
or any of the other pretend saviors would be a fatal
mistake. You are right on in your description of a new
boss going into a tizzy precisely because he doesn't
understand newspapering.
So, what about a "National Tribune" ? Something that
fits the mix between the highbrow grey old lady and
the cartoonish USA Today. Unfortunately, I don't think
that solution works as a fix for short term or long
term problems at the Times. Frankly, the target
demographic (travellers, pols, and the over $100,000
salary crowd) aren't going to read it, they are in the
habit of reading the NYT if they watch CNN and USA
Today if FNC is their preference. The real solution is
going to have to come via the Internet. For the Times
to survive it is going to have to carve out a niche
for itself in the new media -- something that will
make it a hot, buzz worthy property. Something that
will make Google want to shell out the millions (or
billions) for traffic generation. Until then, sadly,
the Times I have grown to love will end up like the
Her-Ex or the typewriter. A distant relic of a bygone
time.
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
Sunday, October 08, 2006
A great opinion piece by Michael Kinsley ran in the LAT sunday. You can read it here
Sunday, September 10, 2006
From Larry Wilson at the Star-News
| Athletes, it's not worth it |
Pasadena Star-News |
| I miss the antic days when Frank Girardot was a staffer here. He was the kind of reporter who would push the envelope just a little bit, and it was fun. Sometimes maybe he pushed too far; still fun. Like the time I picked up the phone to hear Frank exclaim, "Boss, I'm in jail!" "Why are you in jail?" "Well, I'm not really in jail this very second. I'm standing outside the cop shop on Garfield. But I was taken into custody by the PPD after they say I got a little too close to that crime scene this morning and maybe wandered past the barricade - but it was the first barricade, not the yellow tape! And the guy at the first barricade told me I could! And then the guy at the second - hey, I just wanted to ask some questions - hauled me in!" "Come on back to the office, Frank, and we'll talk." Great times, I tell you. Frank now heads up his family's traffic-signal business and lives in Murrieta - next door, as it happens, to Tour de France champion bicyclist Floyd Landis. Frank wrote a funny commentary piece for Sports on Sunday about what Landis is like as a neighbor. Great guy, apparently. He's all about pizza, beer, Lynyrd Skynyrd and fixing Frank's spigots when they leak. Frank has another column in today. Landis also told Frank that doping in biking is cheating and decried the practice. This was all before Landis tested positive for a high level of testosterone so that his yellow jersey is in danger of being taken away. Most of us who follow the sport even casually, who tune in to see a few minutes of those amazing hill climbs in the Pyrenees and the cobblestone finish on the Champs d'Elysee, are finding this a bit dispiriting. Like the baseball situation - can't these jokers just gobble a vitamin each morning and hope for the best? And why, even when they do deny injecting whatever creepy drug or growth hormone they are accused of using, does it usually come down to matters of being found out than of doing it in the first place? "I'm surprised that someone could get caught stupidly after making such a beautiful stage win and winning the Tour," Christophe Basson, a former cyclist with the Francaise du Jeu team, told French television. Such a nice Mennonite boy and all. Here's his mother: "He said, `There's no way.' I really believe him. I don't think he did anything wrong." Well, I hope for U.S. cycling that in a retest it turns out to be just a macho level of the male hormone courses through his veins, or that someone mixed up the test tubes, or something. But if he's caught dead to rights, I hope he and Barry Bonds are assigned to orange-vested trash pick-up duty downtown on Interstate 5 - for the rest of their lives. It must be amazing, to take things so literally. I'm more of a heaven and hell are right here on Earth, plus in your mind when you soar or sin, sort of fellow myself. But on yet another sweltering morning on the way into work Thursday, I loved reading this week's poetically short and to the point marquee message at the Salvation Army Tabernacle, Walnut and Mentor, as I passed it by: "If you think it's hot here ..." |
Friday, July 28, 2006
Fwd: Landis
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Jim Ray <jimraycpa@yahoo.com>
Date: Jul 28, 2006 2:59 PM
Subject: Landis
To: fgirardot@gmail.com
Dear Sir -
I am just an overfed, middle aged guy from Detroit who
wants to say thanks for your piece on Mr. Landis in
last weekend's paper and your column in today's paper
too.
I want to believe that Floyd will be cleared of any
wrongdoing and I am sickened that so many in the media
have prematurely passed judgement. As Gary Wadler of
the WADA has been quoted "It just doesn't add up".
From what I have read, every time this abnormal t/e
situation has occurred in the past it has been
explained away - no one has ever been sanctioned for
it! So I fully expect Floyd to prevail in good time.
Unfortunately it seems his reputation has already been
damaged and he will be stripped of his TDF victory
before all the facts come out.
The next time you see Floyd please thank him and wish
him well for me. His ride in stage 17 was an
inspiration!
Sincerely,
Jim Ray
p.s. you may want to check out this website - http://freefloydlandis.blogspot.com/
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
